The different types of Disclosure Orders, including Norwich Pharmacal and Bankers Trust Orders

November 18, 2026

Victims of fraud or wrongdoing who have suffered financial loss often do not know who is responsible or where their money has gone.

The English courts can order disclosure of documents and information at an early stage, sometimes before proceedings are issued, and sometimes against people who are not wrongdoers themselves but who, usually innocently (sometimes not so innocently), have been caught up in wrongdoing orchestrated by a third party.

We assist with Norwich Pharmacal and Bankers Trust Orders.

Norwich Pharmacal orders

Named after Norwich Pharmacal Co v Customs and Excise Commissioners [1974] AC 133, these orders are available under English law and require a third party who has become “mixed up” in wrongdoing, even innocently, to disclose certain documents or information to the applicant.

Norwich Pharmacal Orders are typically sought against banks and other financial institutions in cases involving fraud. They are sought to enable an applicant to identify a defendant, trace assets and assist in preparing for substantive proceedings.

In some cases, parties often contact the respondent to a proposed Norwich Pharmacal application and engage with them with a view of obtaining information sought by consent either during Pre Action correspondence or during a hearing on paper.

However, in some cases, usually involving banks, information sought is not provided (due to reasons of privacy or duties of confidentiality) without a Court application.

The Civil Procedure Rules do not specifically set out the procedure for applying for a Norwich Pharmacal Order, and therefore, the route taken to obtain an order will often depend on whether proceedings have been commenced or not.

Depending on the circumstances, an applicant may file for proceedings using a Part 8 claim form to obtain the relevant information from a respondent.

Where proceedings have been commenced, it is more likely that a party will file an application under Civil Procedure Rule 23.

When applying to the Court for a Norwich Pharmacal Order, the conditions to be satisfied before the will grant an Order are the following:

  1. A legal wrong must have been carried out by an ultimate wrongdoer. The threshold is that of a ‘good arguable case’;
  2. The person against whom the order is sought must have been involved in the wrongdoing and be likely to be able to provide the information; and
  3. An order for disclosure must be necessary to enable the action to be brought against the ultimate wrong-doer.

If all of the above conditions are satisfied, the Court will then take into account a number of other considerations before deciding whether to grant an Order. These considerations include:

  1. The strength of the case;
  2. The public interest in allowing a claimant to vindicate their rights;
  3. The degree of involvement by the respondent/defendant (i.e. the disclosing party);
  4. To what extent innocent parties may be harmed by the order;
  5. Degree of confidentiality in the order being disclosed;
  6. The relevant privacy and data protection rights.

Bankers Trust Orders

The case of Bankers Trust Co v Shapira [1980] 1 WLR 1274 is usually cited when referring to these types of orders, however, it was not the first case in which such an order was made.

These orders require a bank or a third party to disclose documents, such as account statements, to help a claimant trace funds in which it asserts a proprietary interest.

Bankers Trust Orders are typically granted by a Court where there is strong evidence that the claimant’s money was taken by fraud, and they are often sought urgently and without notice.

In the case of Kyriakou v Christie, Manson & Woods Ltd, the requirements for an applicant seeking a Bankers Trust Order were set out as follows:

  1. Good grounds for considering that the money or assets about which information is sought belonged to the applicant;
  2. A real prospect that the information sought will lead to the recovery or preservation of the property;
  3. The order should be directed at uncovering the location of the property;
  4. The interests of the applicant in obtaining an order should be balanced against detriment to respondents in having to comply with it; and
  5. The applicant must provide undertakings in respect of the information and/or documents sought.

Careful consideration must of course be given to the above requirements before an applicant applies for a Bankers Trust Order. However, if it is necessary and the requirements are met, such an order can prove to be useful to an applicant who has suffered loss as a result of fraud.

While there are similarities between Bankers Trust Orders and Norwich Pharmacal Orders, there are distinct differences

By way of an example, in a Bankers Trust Order an applicant must establish a good arguable case in proving ownership of stolen property, whereas in Norwich Pharmacal Orders an applicant must show that there is a good arguable case of a legally recognised wrong having been committed against them.

Given the similarities of the respective orders, in certain situations, applicants sometimes seek both orders simultaneously.

We also assist with the following types of orders:

Pre-action disclosure

Under Civil Procedure Rule 31.16, the Court can order a likely defendant to disclose documents before proceedings start where both parties are likely to be parties to proceedings, the documents would fall within standard disclosure, and early disclosure is desirable to dispose of the case fairly, assist resolution without proceedings, or save costs.

Non-party disclosure

Once proceedings are underway, Civil Procedure Rule 31.17 allows the Court to order a non-party to disclose documents that are likely to support the applicant’s case or adversely affect another party’s case, where disclosure is necessary to dispose of the claim fairly or to save costs.

These rules do not limit the court’s other powers, including Norwich Pharmacal relief.

Search orders and asset disclosure

In exceptional cases, a search order permits the claimant’s representatives, supervised by an independent solicitor, to enter premises to search for and preserve evidence at real risk of destruction.

Freezing orders are also routinely accompanied by an order requiring the respondent to disclose its assets.

How Mackrell LLP can help

We obtain proprietary, Norwich Pharmacal and Bankers Trust disclosure orders to assist in tracing assets and identifying the movement of funds and we assist foreign clients with evidence and disclosure in England and Wales.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. It reflects the law of England and Wales at the date of publication. Specific legal advice should be taken on your particular circumstances before taking, or refraining from, any action. Please contact Mackrell LLP to discuss your matter.

 

Share this article